New Baldur’s Gate 3 player dismayed by D&D’s “strangely depressing” lore

A screenshot from the game Baldur's Gate 3Larian Studios

A new Baldur’s Gate 3 player entering the world of Faerûn for the first time was taken aback by the “super depressing” setting in which the game takes place.

The world of Dungeons & Dragons that Baldur’s Gate 3 takes most of its cues from is sprawling and immersive, but at the end of the day, it’s a world built from the ground up for things to go wrong. How else would all of those campaigns start?

Article continues after ad

This means there are quite a few more sources of conflict on the Sword Coast than players might expect. After all, in the span of one game (admittedly quite a big one), your party runs into three gods of death, an authoritarian Githyanki queen, several devils, an Elder Brain, and a host of other deities and eldritch abominations. Oh, and the hag.

Baldur’s Gate 3 player finds too many evil gods

All of this makes for a great RPG story, but would you really want to live there? For quite a few players, Baldur’s Gate 3 is their first encounter with the lore of D&D, and it’s easy to see why they might come away with a negative view of life in this world.

Article continues after ad

One player in particular was dismayed by the number of antagonistic deities they ran into, saying: “The more I play, the more it appears the entire universe of BG revolves around various Gods and God-like beings fighting for control/power. From my understanding, the more followers/worshipers they get, the stronger they become.

“But the more I play, the more it really looks like you either join them or get screwed. Everyone below them is basically a pawn for their power play. Except all the Gods suck, even the good ones really come across as mostly selfish.”

Article continues after ad

“Everyone below them is basically stuck in a perpetual cycle of conflict between the various Gods, never-ending. I mean, it’s a great world for a game, since “God-level” conflicts will always arise, and heroes are needed to end the threat of that current cycle, but from an outside perspective, it’d be super depressing to live in this world.”